Hold Fast Apologetics

The Enneagram and the Genetic Fallacy?

Published by

meridith black

on

At the 1:35-minute mark, Rohr explains why the Enneagram is NOT a tool derived through Scientific study and testing. Instead, he provides commentary pertaining to pragmatic helpfulness of its spiritual design. The Enneagram is a man-made tool intended to provide spiritual guidance. But what spirit is giving spiritual advice? Acknowledging this foundational aspect of the Enneagram negates the Genetic Fallacy argument that it can be redeemed for Christian use despite its origins. Seeking spiritual input from fallen angels is not safe. God forbids it (Deuteronomy 18; Acts 19).

What is the Genetic Fallacy?

Per Practical Psychology, “A Genetic Fallacy is when someone judges the value or truth of an idea, person, or thing based solely on its origin, rather than its current context or characteristics.”

For example, we wouldn’t stop calling Thursday, “Thursday,” because it derives its name from Thor. The names of the days of the week do find their origin in pagan gods, but the days of the week are not worshipped…nor are we seeking spiritual guidance from them.

However…

Tarot Cards, Ouija Boards, and the Enneagram are each designed with sole the purpose of gleaning spiritual guidance. Seeking spiritual guidance from spirits other than the one Holy Spirit is placing oneself in the hands of a deceitful spirit— God, in His love for us, forbids this.

Therefore, No— the Enneagram do not pass the Genetic Fallacy argument. These practices & protocols need to be earnestly avoided.

Deuteronomy 18:10-12

For more information regarding the history of the Enneagram, please watch these two videos:

2 minutes
10 minutes
Previous Post
Next Post